Mixed Messages or Best Messages
2.24.2010 | 3 Comments
In 2009, the North Carolina legislature passed a bill that requires schools to teach both abstinence and information about contraception. My local paper featured an article with the familiar refrain from a concerned citizen that “talking about both abstinence and contraception sends mixed messages.”
I have never understood this reasoning.
Don’t we tell our kids not to wander off in the store, but if they do then they should find an adult and tell them they’re lost? Don’t we implore our kids not to play with matches, but tell them that if they start a fire they must tell an adult or call 911 immediately? Don’t we tell teens not to drink when they are underage, but if they do to absolutely not get behind the wheel of a car?
I don’t think those are mixed messages. I think those messages express the expectations of the parent coupled with the acknowledgment that the child has a mind of her/his own and may choose to do the action anyway. Most importantly, those messages also express that even if the child disobeys, the ultimate goal of the parent is still the safety of their child.
There are things I want, and don’t want, to be a part of my children’s lives. But whatever my kids choose to do/say/believe — the thing I most want in their lives is ME. I believe it is my right and my responsibility to share my values with my kids, but I am not under the illusion that they will share all of those values.
I think the best messages are ones that communicate our values AND communicate that whatever happens, our kids will always have our love and support.
To be clear, I support comprehensive sex education and believe that knowledge is power. I believe that the more informed people are, the better choices they will make. I also think that while abstinence until marriage will work for some people, our society needs to be mindful of the fact that it doesn’t work for 95% of the population.
One of the local school board members was quoted in the article as saying,
“Abstinence only. I just think that’s the proper moral thing to do right now as far as my beliefs go.”
As far as my beliefs go, it is the “moral thing” to teach kids how to engage their sexuality in ways that are safe, respectful of themselves and others, and consistent with their values. That may mean abstinence, but it doesn’t have to.






